Top
Close
Follow Us ON
Topics
College Basketball Pittsburgh Syracuse Kansas Oklahoma West Virginia Georgetown Oregon Preview/Prediction LSU College Football Clemson Louisville Syracuse Big 12 Baylor Oklahoma State Oklahoma Texas Tech Texas West Virginia Big Ten - East Ohio State Penn State Big Ten - West Wisconsin Notre Dame Western Michigan Stanford Washington Preview/Prediction Alabama MLB AMERICAN/CENTRAL Chicago White Sox Cleveland Indians Kansas City Royals AMERICAN/EAST Baltimore Orioles Boston Red Sox New York Yankees Toronto Blue Jays AMERICAN/WEST Los Angeles Angels Oakland Athletics Texas Rangers American League Fantasy NATIONAL/CENTRAL Chicago Cubs Cincinnati Reds Milwaukee Brewers Pittsburgh Pirates NATIONAL/EAST Miami Marlins New York Mets Philadelphia Phillies Washington Nationals NATIONAL/WEST Arizona Diamondbacks Los Angeles Dodgers San Diego Padres San Francisco Giants National League Preview/Prediction Rumors NBA Boston Celtics New York Knicks Toronto Raptors Chicago Bulls Cleveland Cavaliers Milwaukee Bucks Washington Wizards Preview/Prediction Rumors Minnesota Timberwolves Oklahoma City Thunder Golden State Warriors Los Angeles Clippers Los Angeles Lakers Sacramento Kings Dallas Mavericks Houston Rockets San Antonio Spurs NFL New England Patriots Cincinnati Bengals Cleveland Browns Pittsburgh Steelers Houston Texans Jacksonville Jaguars Tennessee Titans Denver Broncos Kansas City Chiefs Oakland Raiders NFC East Dallas Cowboys Philadelphia Eagles Washington Redskins Chicago Bears Detroit Lions Green Bay Packers Minnesota Vikings Carolina Panthers San Francisco 49ers Preview/Prediction Rumors NHL EASTERN/ATLANTIC Detroit Red Wings Florida Panthers Montreal Canadiens Tampa Bay Lightning Toronto Maple Leafs Philadelphia Flyers Pittsburgh Penguins Washington Capitals Preview/Prediction Chicago Blackhawks Edmonton Oilers San Jose Sharks General Sports Golf Local Sports Olympics

© 2017 Sports Heaven

Advertise Here Flag

Was changing to the College Football Playoff the right move?

Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

It has been three years since the NCAA moved from the Bowl Championship Series (BCS) computer rankings to determine the National Championship and other bowl games to having a committee make those decisions. At this point college football fans are used to the new system, where a committee votes the teams into the playoffs. Now that it is three years since implementing the new system, is it better than the old BCS system?

There are obvious changes that are pros to some and cons to others. The most obvious change is the creation of a four-team playoff to determine the National Champion opposed to the old system where the two National Championship contenders were selected. This is probably the best change the NCAA made. America loves playoffs and what better way to determine the National Championship than a playoff?

On the other hand, some people will argue that with the new system, it takes away from the importance of the other four major bowl games that are not a part of the playoffs. While this may be true, it also increases the importance of winning a National Championship, which should be the ultimate goal.

Having a playoff is better than having no playoff at all so the College Football Playoff are already better than the BCS. However, this year is showing that increasing the size of the Playoff may be something the NCAA should do.

There is a decent chance that 9-2 Louisville will miss the playoffs and many argue that they should have a shot at a National Championship given how good they are. The problem is that the playoffs cannot be expanded too much. There can’t be a March Madness sized playoff.

On the other hand, increasing the pool to six teams, giving two byes, or eight teams does seem to make sense. Any more than eight teams and there are too many games.

The new system also gives teams the possibility of losing a game or two early in the season and then bounce back and earn the votes of the committee rather than being taken out of National Championship contention early in the season because of the way the BCS system was set up. It’s similar in regards to March Madness but on a smaller scale.

One thing the BCS system did which made regular season games more interesting is that it made every game a little more important. With two less teams and a computer system, one loss could virtually eliminated a team’s chances, making every game a must win.

College football was the only major sport in America in which the championship game was not determined by a playoff. It just makes sense to create the playoff. In the end, the NCAA cares about money. When fans are happy they make more money. In 2012, ESPN conducted a poll in which 77% of respondents prefered a playoff system over the BCS.

The NCAA gave the fans what they want and it was the right idea. There are still changes that can be made, but college football is better now than it was three years ago.

Show Comments
Load